Click Here to Return to the Piping Design Central Main Page Click Here for the Site Index
Visit the COADE website, click here



Today is 



"Cheap Man Pays Twice VII"

(A favorite saying of a Russian woman I worked with)

Discipline Interference

By Dennis Novotny

There are many stories that this phrase brings to mind, and this is one of them...


We had to pre-purchase some cement-lined pipe for two slurry lines from a hopper into a receiving tank inside a building. And that meant design early on in the project. We were nervous; it was expensive pipe and it had to be right. All involved agonized over the design, but finally it was issued.


Months later, we got a call: "It doesn't fit!" After the initial response of looking for someone to blame, the drawings came out and were checked again. We couldn't find a thing wrong. We talked to construction.


"What exactly is wrong?"


"You ran right through the main electrical feeders!"


"We what?!"


This conversation continued for a while until we realized what had happened. Have you ever heard (or used) the phrase "We were there first!"? In this case, we were, but winning didn't help. The decision had been made (by the cheap owner) to do the electrical design without drawings, just let the contractor loose. And he did and pulled his power cables through our space. His cables were cut and installed; case closed. We had to move the pipe.


It was an interesting problem; the pipe had to be used as purchased. There was no time (or money) to reorder. We worked it out, but it wasn't pretty. What had been a flowing layout with 45° elbows was now something no one wanted to acknowledge. But it went in, and apparently operated as it was supposed to. But it was ugly! We paid with the extra work, and probably are still unknowingly paying every time some one looks at that pipe and says "Ugly!"


Moral? How about the need to communicate? Had we known, we could have contacted the electrical contractor and done some coordination. Or, as the timing had worked out, he could have seen our drawings and missed our pipe.


Any one else out there have any more "Morals" derived from this story? Or do you have a "Cheap man pays twice" story? Please send them in. I'd love to hear them.


Dennis Novotny
© 06 June 2001

Copyright 1998 - 2008 PipingDesign.com
Contact:
ISSN 1496-3426
Product trademarks mentioned herein remain the property of their respective owners.

PipingDesign.com and its authors claim no responsibility for the accuracy or currency of the information contained at sites linked therein. Technical articles submitted by readers and published at PipingDesign.com remain the property of the original author (unless otherwise noted). PipingDesign.com does not verify the technical validity of user-submitted articles or software. Products offered through PipingDesign.com are guaranteed by the original manufacturers.